In the heart of downtown Lebanon, Ohio, The Golden Lamb and its cozy companion, Black Horse Tavern, are more than just dining spots—they’re living pieces of history. As a former Lebanon High School English teacher turned real estate agent, I have witnessed the evolution of this landmark which mirrors the story of the town itself: full of charm, nostalgia, and a steady beat of renewal.
Having taught generations of Lebanon students, I’ve watched this town grow from a quiet community with just a few shops and diners into a vibrant destination where history and progress walk hand in hand. These days, I have the joy of helping many of my former students buy their first homes right back here in their hometown. And for many of my clients who are Lebanon locals, celebrating a home purchase—or any of life’s big milestones—just isn’t complete without a celebratory lunch or dinner at The Golden Lamb.
Ohio’s Oldest Inn, Steeped in Stories
Established in 1803—the same year Ohio became a state—The Golden Lamb holds the title of Ohio’s oldest continuously operating business. Over the past two centuries, it has hosted twelve U.S. Presidents, from John Quincy Adams to George W. Bush, as well as historical icons like Charles Dickens, Harriet Beecher Stowe, and Mark Twain. Its walls echo the stories of travelers, politicians, authors, and everyday folks who’ve stopped in for a warm meal and good conversation.
Every dining room is steeped in character, filled with antiques, vintage wallpaper, and framed letters from centuries past. If you’re lucky, you might catch local historian John Zimkus (also a former Lebanon teacher!) making his rounds—he’s a treasure trove of tales, ready to share the lesser-known stories behind the inn’s famous guests and ghostly rumors.
Two Dining Experiences, One Memorable Meal
While The Golden Lamb side offers a more traditional, white-tablecloth dining experience in historic surroundings, Black Horse Tavern offers something a little more relaxed. Styled like a proper English pub, it features dark wood interiors, a glowing fireplace, and a down-to-earth atmosphere that instantly feels like home. And unlike The Golden Lamb, whose reservation list is often booked months in advance, Black Horse Tavern is first-come, first-serve, offering an accessible fine-dining experience for more spontaneous occasions.
Black Horse is one of my favorite spots for a casual bite or drink, especially in the warmer months when you can sit on the covered patio. (Pro tip: the outdoor heaters make it cozy even when the weather cools off.)
What to Order
Still on the menu—and still delicious—the Signature House Salad and the Sliced Tenderloin Sandwich are two of my go-to picks. Thursday nights are especially fun, with Gourmet Burger & Craft Beer Night kicking off at 4 p.m., and Friday evenings feature Weekend Craft Cocktails starting at 4 p.m. The Black Horse Tavern may not have traditional beer taps lining the bar, but the wine list is thoughtful, the bourbon selection is impressive, and the hospitality is always on point.
Why It’s Worth the Visit
Whether you’re planning a family dinner, a business lunch, or just want to experience a piece of Ohio history, The Golden Lamb and Black Horse Tavern deliver more than just a great meal. They offer a connection—to the past, to the community, and to the people who’ve called this town home for generations.
From a former Lebanon Hight School teacher, I can say there’s no better place to raise a toast to old memories—and make some new ones too.
