There is something about pizza night that always feels like a celebration. Whether it is a casual weeknight dinner or a reason to gather with friends, pizza brings people together.
And in Dayton, that love for a good slice runs deep.
In honor of National Pizza Day on February 9th, we are spotlighting local spots that define the city’s pizza scene. From classic thin crust to bold, creative pies, these pizzerias prove there is no wrong way to do pizza night in the Gem City.
Old Scratch Pizza
With locations in Dayton, Centerville, Beavercreek, and Troy, Old Scratch Pizza has become a true community favorite. Their original location transformed an abandoned 1960s auto parts store into a lively pizza and beer hall that still feels like one of Dayton’s best-kept secrets.
What makes it special:
- Modern, wood-fired pizza style
- Welcoming, social atmosphere
- Creative flavor combinations
Fan favorites:
- Angry Beekeeper with tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil, spicy salami, and house hot honey
- The Dayton, a perfectly done classic pepperoni pie
Joe’s Pizzeria
For more than 60 years, Joe’s Pizzeria has been serving what many locals consider the original Dayton slice. This downtown staple keeps things simple with a traditional style that feels like stepping into a classic neighborhood pizza joint.
Why locals love it:
- Over six decades of Dayton pizza history
- No-frills, old-school atmosphere
- Consistently classic pies that never go out of style
If you are craving comfort, nostalgia, and a slice that feels familiar in the best way, Joe’s delivers every time.
Marion’s Piazza
Few names are as iconic in Dayton as Marion’s Piazza. Since 1965, this local institution has helped shape the way the city enjoys pizza. It was also one of Dayton’s first full-service pizzerias.
Marion’s introduced the thin crust, square-cut style that many now know as Dayton-style pizza.
Must-try favorites:
- Marion’s Deluxe
- Super Cheese
- Ham and Sauerkraut pizza for the adventurous eater
With nine locations across the area, Marion’s continues to be a go-to for generations of Dayton families.
Red Bird Pizza
Located in Miamisburg, Red Bird Pizza brings East Coast inspiration to the Miami Valley. Their New York-style pies and unique crust-making process set them apart from the crowd.
Why it stands out:
- East Coast–inspired approach
- Creative topping combinations
- Pizza flight nights to sample multiple pies
Popular picks:
- The Carm with caramelized onion puree, fresh mozzarella, whipped lemon ricotta, and basil oil
- The Toussaint with tomato sauce, blue oyster mushrooms, shallot, and parmesan
Old Dayton Pizza
If award-winning pizza is what you are after, Old Dayton Pizza delivers. This downtown favorite earned first place at the Midwestern Pizza Competition in 2024 and keeps locals coming back for more.
What to expect:
- Roman-style dough
- Fun bar and pizza joint atmosphere
- Games and an outdoor fireplace for year-round hangouts
It is the kind of place where pizza night easily turns into an all-evening affair.
Wheat Penny Oven and Bar
Wheat Penny Oven and Bar blends rustic charm with thoughtfully sourced ingredients. Known for their California-style pies, this downtown spot puts a fresh spin on familiar favorites.
Beyond pizza, you will find:
- Italian-inspired sandwiches
- House-made pasta dishes
- A menu that feels personal and creative
Standout pies:
- Unbeetable with beet pesto, spinach, and whipped goat cheese
- Chimi Picante with chimichurri, braised pork, smoked provolone, and peppadews
Every dish reflects the heart and personality behind the restaurant.
Yellow Cab Tavern
Formerly known as Pizza Bandit, Yellow Cab Tavern is a go-to late-night stop for New York-style slices in downtown Dayton. The vibe is casual, fun, and perfect for ending an evening with friends.
Why people love it:
- Late-night hours
- Bold, creative pizza combinations
- Relaxed tavern atmosphere
Signature pies:
- Everything Bagel Pickle Pizza with a garlic and cream cheese base, mozzarella, provolone, dill pickles, and everything seasoning
- Action Jackson Special Deluxe loaded with pepperoni, sausage, salami, mushrooms, and pepper relish
From longtime institutions to creative newcomers, Dayton’s pizza scene has something for every kind of craving. This National Pizza Day, consider skipping your usual order and trying a new local favorite instead.
You might just discover your next go-to spot for pizza night, Dayton-style.
For more foodie favorites and adventures in the Gem City, explore our Dayton blog library.
