Pizza

Pizza Night Picks: 5 Must-Try Local Pizzerias

I’ve discovered that one of the best ways to connect with friends and family is over a delicious slice of pizza. Whether you’re planning a cozy night in or looking for a fun outing, the tri-state area is home to incredible pizzerias that each offer a unique experience. Here’s a roundup of five local favorites that will make any pizza night a memorable one!

Adriatico’s

Located in the heart of Clifton, Adriatico’s has been a popular destination for students and families since the 1990s. The friendly and relaxed atmosphere makes it perfect for a casual meal with friends. Known for their delicious, thick, and cheesy pizza slices, Adriatico’s features a perfect crust topped with rich tomato sauce and fresh ingredients. If you’re particularly hungry, be sure to try the Bearcat-sized pizza, which measures 18″ x 24″.

Things to enjoy in the area:

UC Game
Cincinnati Zoo & Botanical Garden
Bogarts

TAGLIO

For those seeking a unique blend of creativity and tradition, TAGLIO in Columbia Tusculum serves up artisanal pizzas that are truly works of art. Each pie features seasonal ingredients, providing a fresh twist on classic flavors. The ambiance is trendy yet relaxed, making it a suitable spot for a night out or a laid-back dinner. Try the “Margarita” topped with fresh basil and mozzarella, or the “Fennel Sausage” for a flavorful kick. Pair your meal with one of their craft beers or a local wine to elevate the experience!

Things to enjoy in the area:

Bengals Game
FC Cincinnati Game
Reds Game

Saint Francis Apizza

Check out one of my favorite spots in Hyde Park—Saint Francis Apizza. This family-operated, takeout-only pizzeria makes everything from scratch and features local ingredients. Their pizza style, served Tuesday to Sunday, is inspired by the best of New York, New Haven, and Portland. Each slice showcases true artisan craftsmanship. Don’t forget their Monday special—an incredible Chicago-style pizza that adds a unique twist to the menu. Take home to enjoy or get outside and explore a local park.

Things to enjoy in the area:

Ault Park
Alms Park
Owls Nest Park

A Tavola

If you’re craving authentic Italian pizza, A Tavola is a must-visit. This charming eatery encapsulates the spirit of traditional Italian trattorias found in cities like Naples and Florence, serving not just food but also a welcoming atmosphere that feels like an extension of your own dining room.

Things to enjoy in the area:

The Nelle V. Hosbrook Bird Sanctuary
McDonald Commons Park
Sellman Park

Your Mom’s Pizzeria

Nestled in the heart of Mt. Adams, Your Mom’s Pizzeria offers a delightful taste of authentic New York-style pizza that’s sure to impress. Family-owned and operated, this cozy spot prides itself on serving up pies made from a special blend of mozzarella and provolone cheese, combined with their cherished family recipe for pizza dough. Whether you’re in the mood for one of their specialty pizzas or want to unleash your creativity with a custom creation, every mouthful is a treat. Don’t forget to try their famous garlic knots for an irresistible side!

Things to enjoy in the area:

Cincinnati Art Museum
Eden Park
Cincinnati Playhouse in the Park

Have a Slice

No matter which pizzeria you choose, each spot promises a delightful experience that goes beyond just the food. So grab your favorite people, make it a pizza night, and explore the incredible local flavors of the tri-state area! Happy pizza eating!

Love these local spotlights? See more insights from your local neighborhood guide, Mark Schupp.